Dual Halal and Kosher Certification of Food

Dual Halal and Kosher Certification of Food

The Controversy and Fixing the Situation

Today we received an inquiry from another state institution system confused about what dual certification means and how it affects the Halal certified food programs they want to implement.  This relatively new and evolving product type creates a wrinkle to institutions sincerely trying to provide proper, religiously supervised and produced, halal certified foods to their clientele.

Vegetarian and Non-Meat Ingredient Food Products

However, this created years during which we deflected the vocal criticism from the Jewish community, including both agencies and consumers.  Jewish consumers claimed they did not want to pay for the cost of Islamic certification fees which they thought must be included in our pricing of our meals.  Kosher food certification agencies charged that it just was not a good idea.

Fast forward to about six years ago

After decades of responding to Jewish concerns, the groundswell began shifting to Muslims starting to complain to institutions about serving them vegetarian, dual-certified, kosher and halal certified food.  Mistrust was caused from the known and pervasive practice of corrupt Islamic certifying agencies lending their halal food certification symbol for a fee to any kosher product without further investigation and on-site work.  We easily resolved such questions about our products, presenting the benefits from our experience of properly preparing, producing, marketing and supplying dual certified vegetarian meals, but now it was to Muslim, not Jewish, consumers.

Certified Meat Meals Are a Different Story

halal-certified-beefReligiously certified meat such as beef, lamb or goat, can only be from animals physically slaughtered by one person, and that slaughter man is either a Jew or Muslim, but not both.  It is true that some Muslim consumers will personally accept kosher-slaughtered meat as a “halal-substitute”, but those purchasers buy kosher certified meat knowing that it is kosher and not halal.

chicken-halal-certified-poultryIt is also true that some Islamic certified poultry is mechanically slaughtered under the supervision and prayers of a devout and trained Muslim, principally because the hand-slaughter poultry industry is not well-developed in the US.  In contrast, mechanical slaughter is prohibited for kosher birds which must only be slaughtered by hand and inspected by a trained Jewish slaughter man known as a shochet.

New Problems for Certification Institutions

chef preparing certified mealsRecently and for a variety of reasons, some marketers are putting both a kosher and a halal certified symbol on their prepared meal products, usually marketed to Muslims.  This typically happens because an Islamic certifying agency “certifies” that kosher meat is halal because the Islamic certifier himself accepts kosher in place of halal slaughter, and is willing to put his halal “stamp of approval” symbol on the package.

Yet, since only one Muslim or one Jew can slaughter the animal, which one is it?  Is it a kosher certified meat product accepted by the halal agency?  Or is it a halal certified meat product accepted by the kosher agency?  The confusion is destined to create headaches for food service providers and institutions, and perhaps to the entire halal and kosher certifying industries.

Although doubtful, could the practice of dual certified meat and poultry perhaps eventually become acceptable to both Muslim and Jewish consumers and actually unify the two religions?  For now, it is likely best to serve separately certified meat meals to each consumer according to his or her respective religion.


Halal Food Certification Standards

Welcome back!

halal food certification presentation

IFANCA’s 19th Annual International Halal Food Conference. Mary Anne Jackson presents on Halal Food Certification Standards.

At IFANCA’s 19th Annual International Halal Food Conference on April 17-19 in Chicago, Illinois. I moderated a panel focused on halal food certification standards.  The panel specifically discussed issues and problems related to halal meat product production and is the subject of today’s blog.

Halal Food Certification Standards: A History

Twenty-six years ago, we entered the halal market. Our entry began with evaluating, and defining what halal certification meant and represented.  We found that halal standards were loose or non-existent.  And no one was monitoring or holding halal certifying agencies and their employees accountable for their actions or practices, both in the US and internationally.

Some examples of what we found

  • A Chicago-land grocery store sold pita bread with an IFANCA symbol on it; yet it was an unauthorized use of IFANCA’s trademark and only found by chance.
  • International websites, particularly from China, claimed halal certification by displaying unauthorized symbols of reputable halal certifying agencies.
  • We found “self-certification” where “independent” halal certifiers had a financial interest in a meat company they certified. This lack of independence brings into question the reliability of any certification.
  • One halal certifier told us that it did not matter if the product they certified was indeed halal because the consumer was protected. As Muslims, the certifying Muslim would suffer in hell, not the consumer.
  • More recently, one halal agency certified meat as Islamic-slaughtered for export, yet the meat supplier’s standards were not authorized for export to the importing country. To obfuscate the breach in halal and export standards to the USDA and the customer, the halal agency and meat company went further by illegally putting USDA labels from an approved-for-export company on the packages to conceal the actual producer.

Competing in the Halal Market

We also learned that if a Muslim claimed something was halal, consumers and customers accepted the statement with little or no further investigation.  Halal Certificates could easily be obtained for a fee.  As bad as it was in the US, Europe was at least as bad making it more difficult for US businesses to compete with imports documented with dubious halal certificates.  Many American businesses following strict halal standards had to compete internationally and domestically with products “certified” in such a controversial manner.

Meeting Halal Market Expectations

Acceptable halal standards can vary because consumers have differing opinions of what is or is not suitable.  As in kosher, no single set of standards defines what is acceptable. However, the Muslim community can protect its halal customers by implementing simple requirements.

While some halal consumers will accept kosher certification even for meat, kosher is not a direct substitute for halal certification.   A halal agency should not be permitted to label and put its halal symbol on kosher meat/poultry products implying halal slaughter when all it is doing is expressing that kosher is acceptable as a halal substitute.  Jews are not even permitted to slaughter meat if they know it is intended for non-kosher consumers.

For products to be labeled and certified as halal, specific standards should be met and disclosed. We believe each halal agency should publicly publish its slaughter practices and certifying standards as a post on its website or articles in journals.

Let halal consumers decide based upon accurate information and leave kosher products as kosher certified so that halal consumers know what they are buying.  Require halal agencies to publish and disclose their standards.

Facilitating Trade: Defining Halal Standards

Most Islamic countries only permit halal food products to be imported into their country if they are certified by approved or accredited halal agencies.  Malaysia, Indonesia, United Arab Emirates, and Saudi Arabia have this requirement unlike products entering the US, which means there is the potential for shenanigans in the US market.

To communicate what halal certification means for domestic and imported products, we believe it is critical that the US Islamic community:

  • clearly define halal food standards, and
  • establish accreditation of certifying agencies.

Government Role in Importing and Exporting

For those Islamic countries to which US companies can export, USDA APHIS publishes on its website those rules and standards required by each country.

However, for halal products imported into the US, the Islamic community has not yet created required halal standards which the USDA-APHIS could monitor, nor are there lists of accepted foreign halal certifiers. This means the US government can only publish the general rules of importation without regard to halal certification on its website.

Setting Halal Food Certification Standards


The importance of halal certification is high and we are working to close the gap with much needed standards.

We believe that no one likely cares as much about what constitutes halal as the people who will be consuming and using halal products.  We also believe the US Government should not be expected to define halal standards.  Its role should be as a monitor to assure that the rules established by the halal community are followed for imports and products produced in the US.  It can verify the certifying agencies are on an approved list of certifiers, and that the paperwork is in order.  The government’s role should only be to assure importers, exporters and domestic producers comply with the same set of documented rules.

Policing and Protecting the Halal Market

Once halal agencies publish their standards, then an organization of accreditors could be established to recognize and monitor their activities by:

  • monitoring the certifying agencies to assure they follow the practices they publish
  • informing the halal market of halal and labeling violations
  • reporting products carrying an unauthorized certifying agency’s symbol
  • reporting changes in standards at a halal certifying agency
  • and generally, monitoring the market and informing halal consumers.

Violations to accreditation might include:

  • halal agencies found violating civil or religious laws
  • halal agencies failing to follow its own published standards
  • or other violations against its agreement for accreditation.

For the accreditation process to be meaningful, violators could lose their accreditation until violations are corrected.

Final Words:  Halal Certification

The issue of halal certification standards is complicated but is gaining international recognition.  While efforts are underway in the US to create an accreditation process of halal agencies and to define basic halal standards, it is difficult to find a reputable organization willing to champion this process. An accreditation board must be an independent authority with the stamina to withstand scrutiny and criticism.  It would also be charged to establish and monitor basic halal standards, which will most assuredly be interpreted differently by those implementing them.

I am sure we will be discussing this subject for some years to come because even twenty-six year later, it is still in its early stages.

halal chicken

Halal Chicken: What, Why, and Handling Certification

All of us here at J&M Food Products Company thank you for joining us at our new blog!  Please share our stories with friends through Twitter, Facebook and other social media and email us your comments or ideas. Today we will talk about halal chicken.  Let’s get started.

Halal Chickens: What are they?

halal chicken standardsTo be a halal chicken is simple. It must be healthy and alive prior to halal slaughter. To prepare it for human consumption is where there is international controversy and conflict. This conflict is a two-part segment at IFANCA’s 19th Annual International Halal Food Conference April 17-19 (Chicago). The more I learn about practices in other countries, the more I realize that we need certifying agencies to publish the standards they practice for the end user to make an informed purchase. 

Handling of Halal Chickens

what is halal chickenHand-slaughter vs Mechanical Slaughter of Chickens: The subject of halal chicken slaughter is a sensitive subject to many people, and in the halal community it is laden with problems.

The preference under halal standards is to require poultry be slaughtered by hand.  Slower hand slaughter lines make it easier to assure each chicken is properly blessed at the exact moment of slaughter. Unlike a machine, a human is capable of reason and understanding that is needed to respect the life of the animal to be consumed as food.

Our halal certifying agency prefers hand-slaughter of chickens. However, they also prefer that Muslims can enjoy halal prepared meals to eat away from home instead of always having to resort to vegetarian-only, non-halal or kosher meals locally available.  For now, hand-slaughtered, halal chickens are not always available due to supply limitations.


Halal Chicken in J&M® Products and Other Prepared Chicken Meals

Unfortunately, as we learned, trying to buy hand-slaughtered chicken ingredients, not all halal chicken certifiers use the preferred techniques. This is particularly problematic when chicken is an ingredient in a meal like ours vs when a consumer buys a chicken at his/her local halal meat market. When we were sourcing hand-slaughtered chicken for potential business, our team traced one supplier’s “hand-slaughtered”, halal chicken back through the supply chain levels using the USDA facility number. This led to us to discover that the location of the actual slaughterhouse for the chicken actually came from a facility that used only mechanical slaughter.

As a shelf-stable meals company, we must use pre-cooked halal meat and poultry as ingredients in our USDA production facility. To buy enough cooked halal chicken for production of our meals, we first find a chicken cooking plant willing to convert its cooking operations over to halal inspected cooking. Then, we must work with that processor to source enough raw, chilled and iced (not frozen) halal slaughtered chicken to ship to them to cook.

Today, hand-slaughter facilities are small and scattered and most commonly supply retail stores. Most US chicken slaughtering facilities which supply cooking plants in the United States are set up for high volume mechanical slaughter. Therefore, we work with mechanical slaughtering facilities to meet the tonnage requirements. Since they are set up for high volume machine slaughter, they are not inclined to add a small line for hand slaughter that would qualify for halal meat production.  This supply and demand circle can only be closed once there are enough halal hand-slaughter facilities to supply the demands of the market.

The smaller hand-slaughter facilities cannot supply enough halal chickens in a day to ship enough tonnage to a nearby halal chicken processing plant to cook. So, we must work with our halal certification agency to resolve this dilemma.

Halal Certification: Why It Matters

While the hand-slaughtered chicken supply network develops in the US, our halal certification agency requires a special procedure of mechanical slaughter which mirrors hand-slaughter as a temporarily acceptable alternative.  Our agency requires the mechanical slaughterhouse to slow the line and hire enough additional trained slaughter men to relieve each other in reciting the blessing and to catch any birds missed by mechanical means or not blessed.  In this way, each halal chicken is blessed as if under hand slaughter by a trained Islamic inspector, thus, providing the respect of the life being taken to supply Muslims with food. This is a stricter practice than most other certifying agencies both in the US and from other countries.  For example, some countries such as Australia do not even require a blessing over each bird for the slaughter to be labeled halal. Instead, the Australian Government only requires a blessing over the entire flock at the beginning of the day, and nothing more during the slaughter to be labeled “halal”.  The definition of about how to respect the chicken’s life to meet halal standards varies by agency and country standards often leaving consumers uninformed.

Thank you for reading and please come back again. We plan to have a posting at least once a month on a variety of subjects. Next month’s post will be about IFANCA’s 19th Annual International Halal Food Conference April 17-19 (Chicago) where I will moderate a panel discussing halal slaughtering issues